Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Owen's avatar

Cortana and the Windows Phone. Cortana was so much more useful and responsive than Siri, and did so many more intelligent things for me (like "remind me to buy a cat toy next time I'm at petsmart", or "schedule a meeting with Greg at the earliest opportunity"). Cortana lacked the ecosystem of Siri and Alexa and Google, relying on an open market for devices that never appeared. Windows Phone was trashed left and right by the sheeple, fanboys, and pundits, but I still miss those live tiles. One glance and I got weather, messages, headlines, inspiration. Didn't need the notification screen, didn't need to tap into apps to figure out the red dot. And gestures were welcome -- putting your phone face-down on the table to DND, face up when you don't mind being interreupted. I occasionally read an article now and then about how much the market needs a viable third phone OS. But alas.

Alexa annoys me to death. I used to have a half dozen around my house. Now I have PTSD and my trigger words are "by the way....". Amazon Prime includes a bunch of free music, and that used to be cool. But the incessant ads are killing it for me. Apple music isn't much better. I listen to music with explicit lyrics, but three songs in Apple Music has somehow decided I want to hear radio edits only and three songs after that it's playing Baby Shark.

But it's not just these platforms. Advertising is popping up everywhere I don't want it. And it's pervasive and overwhelming. I don't know if persistent robocalling for extended auto warranties eventually got people to buy them, but I know being overwhelmed with upsells and subscription offers is pushing me the other direction. I don't need that. I don't want that. I just want the lights to turn on when I say, "Alexa, turn on the bedroom lights" and not hear the dreaded, "By the way, customers like you also purchased 50 gallon vats of industrial lubricant. Would you like me to add it to your shopping cart?"

Expand full comment
David Fleetwood's avatar

AI is this decade's voice computing. As usual they are knocking off the low hanging fruit creating the illusion of exponential progress but that final 10% will prove economically not worth it. Then it will decay. I suspect it will be even worse than voice & AR/VR given that like self-driving cars they have done zero significant work on the regulatory & legal side and people are getting wise to that more quickly today than they did in the past decade. I expect an avalanche of IP lawsuits and large amounts of data/content being closed off to AI models.

Expand full comment
15 more comments...

No posts